News Summary
Arizona Republican lawmakers, led by Rep. Matt Gress, are advocating for a proposal that ties teacher pay raises to school voucher rights. This could lead to a $4,000 pay increase for teachers. However, Governor Katie Hobbs has rejected the plan, arguing it undermines necessary salary increases and educational equity. The ongoing negotiations reflect deep partisan divides regarding funding priorities in the state’s education system, especially as previous attempts to expand voucher programs have faced voter backlash.
Phoenix, Arizona – Arizona Republican lawmakers, led by House Education Committee Chairman Rep. Matt Gress, are pushing for a controversial proposal that links potential voter initiatives for teacher pay raises to a constitutional right for school vouchers for private and parochial education. This proposal could mean a $4,000 across-the-board salary increase for teachers, aiming to elevate Arizona’s average teacher salaries above the national average.
Rep. Gress indicated that a sizable faction of House and Senate Republicans likely supports this dual approach, emphasizing the need for constitutional protections for school choice. They argue this is critical in light of past initiatives led by Democratic Governor Katie Hobbs, who they claim has sought to limit the options available to families regarding education through programs such as Empowerment Scholarship Accounts (ESAs).
Governor Hobbs has publicly rejected the GOP’s proposal, deeming it a “complete and total nonstarter.” She points out that the business community and educational leaders are against this strategy and has called for an end to partisan politics that could obstruct necessary salary increases for teachers.
As negotiations to extend Proposition 123 unfold, which currently supports K-12 education funding, differences between the parties remain stark. Republicans argue that all funds must be used for teacher salaries. In contrast, Governor Hobbs seeks to use some of these funds for support staff, general school funding, and safety measures in schools. Her administration has also proposed a compromise regarding ESAs, suggesting that eligibility would be linked to family income levels. Families earning up to $100,000 would maintain full access to these accounts, with benefits gradually decreasing for those with higher incomes.
The push for a constitutional amendment could face significant backlash from voters. Previous efforts to expand voucher programs have met with disapproval, making it uncertain whether a referendum on such measures would be successful. The original Proposition 123, which narrowly passed with a 51-49 vote, allocated approximately $3.5 billion for K-12 education, but whether linking salary increases to constitutional amendments for vouchers would garner the same support remains questionable.
Vouchers in Arizona have evolved from serving primarily special needs students to nearly universal eligibility for all students, reflecting a significant shift in education funding policies. The current voucher program, launched in 2022, has dramatically increased enrollment, with over 87,000 students benefitting from this initiative, amounting to an expenditure of over $770 million annually.
Critics of the voucher system maintain that its expansion has disproportionately aided wealthier families, leaving low-income families with limited access due to the costs associated with private education. Education advocates express concern about the potential for waste and a lack of accountability in schools that receive funding through vouchers, fearing that this could lead to an uneven distribution of educational resources.
Developing a constitutional amendment to protect vouchers may complicate potential reforms in the future, as any proposed changes could face higher hurdles once codified into the state constitution. As these debates continue among lawmakers, the future of teacher pay, educational choice, and funding equity remains uncertain in Arizona.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
LDS Church Terminates Agreement with Vail School District
Immigration Attorney Receives Self-Deportation Notice in Arizona
Arizona Governor Signs Bill to Advance Axon Enterprise Development
Arizona’s Housing Crisis: Rising Costs and Limited Options
Additional Resources
- Click2Houston: Arizona School Vouchers
- AZCentral: Arizona School Voucher Opinion
- KVOA: Tucson Parent Debate on Vouchers
- Statesman: Opinion on Low-Income Families and Vouchers
- Newsweek: School Vouchers Report
- Wikipedia: School Vouchers
- Google Search: School Vouchers
- Google Scholar: School Vouchers
- Encyclopedia Britannica: School Vouchers
- Google News: School Vouchers
