News Summary
John R. Davis Elementary School in Phoenix is set to close permanently, reflecting wider trends of declining enrollment linked to Arizona’s school choice policies. The Roosevelt School District has faced significant challenges with dwindling student numbers and competition from charter schools. Supporters of school choice advocate for better educational outcomes, while critics raise concerns about funding for public education. The district’s plan to manage its $5 million deficit includes this closure, which has drawn emotional responses from the community, highlighting the complex issues surrounding educational access and equity.
PHOENIX, AZ – John R. Davis Elementary School, which has served the community for 43 years, is set to close permanently, marking a significant loss for local families. The closure, announced by the Roosevelt Elementary School District, is part of a larger trend driven by declining student enrollment linked to Arizona’s expanding school choice policies. The district, once home to 18 operational schools, has seen its numbers dwindle to just 13, a change indicative of a statewide issue.
Arizona’s school choice framework allows parents to direct taxpayer funding toward various educational alternatives, including charter schools and private institutions. The result has been a disturbing decline in public school attendance; in 2021, only 75% of Arizona children attended public schools, the lowest rate nationwide.
Supporters of school choice argue that families are increasingly seeking better educational outcomes for their children, often citing dissatisfaction with public schools, while critics warn that voucher systems drain state resources from essential public education funding. Additionally, they express concern over lack of accountability since private schools may choose their students and are not obliged to administer state tests. This controversy has intensified as Arizona introduced a universal voucher program in 2022, allowing all families access to funds for private or homeschooling.
The Roosevelt Elementary School District is emblematic of these broader trends. Enrollment has plummeted from approximately 10,500 students in 2010 to just over 7,000 this past year, reflecting a loss of over 30% of its student population. Many families have chosen alternative education options due to the district’s longstanding reputation for poor performance. In recent years, only 13% of students in the district achieved proficiency in math, a statistic that has further discouraged parents from enrolling their children in Roosevelt schools.
Compounding the issue, the Roosevelt district is navigating a competitive landscape featuring 21 charter schools that operate either within or around its boundaries, all vying for the same student pool. This heightened competition is particularly challenging given that the overall school-age population in Arizona remains steady while the general population continues to grow.
In response to these fiscal and enrollment challenges, Superintendent Dani Portillo unveiled a strategic initiative called “Reinventing Roosevelt” aimed at addressing the district’s $5 million deficit. The plan includes the controversial decision to close John R. Davis Elementary School, which has drawn emotional responses from community members. Many parents voiced their frustrations during community meetings, expressing anger at the diminishing options for public education in their locality.
The district is primarily composed of a racially diverse and low-income student body, with over 80% of its students identifying as Hispanic and 13% as Black. Approximately 800 students currently utilize the state’s Empowerment Scholarship Account program, which provides funds for private education, thus impacting overall district enrollment further.
The impact of school closures isn’t just felt by students; many teachers affected by these changes will be reassigned to other schools within the district, an effort to address community concerns about job losses. Nevertheless, the historical performance issues faced by the Roosevelt district create a complex scenario for regaining student trust and stabilizing enrollment.
The financial implications of Arizona’s school choice policies cannot be overlooked, with projections suggesting that private education funding through vouchers could exceed $1 billion annually. This scenario presents a formidable challenge to the state’s budget and public education funding viability.
As Arizona continues to grapple with the realities of school choice and enrollment declines, the Roosevelt district’s struggles serve as a microcosm of a larger nationwide debate about education accessibility, equity, and accountability. The district’s future remains uncertain as it seeks to navigate these demanding circumstances while striving to meet the educational needs of its community.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
NFL Players Association Appoints David White as Interim Executive Director
Vallejo School District Recommends Closure of Lincoln Elementary
Exploring the Impact of School Closures on Phoenix Communities
CVS to Close Pharmacy in Phoenix Near VA Medical Center
Arizona Investigates Nearly $50 Million in Dormant School Voucher Funds
Tempe Elementary School District Tops Arizona Rankings
Top 10 Private Schools in Arizona Announced for 2025
Legacy Traditional Schools Tops Arizona Charter Rankings 2025
Phoenix Elementary School District to Close Two Schools
Valley Schools Receive Grants for Healthy Eating Programs
Additional Resources
- Washington Post: Arizona Public School Closures
- Axios: Federal Voucher Arizona School Choice
- Idaho Capital Sun: Arizona’s $800 Million School Choice Program
- Governing: Who Really Benefits from Universal School Choice
- Washington Post: Image Resource
- Wikipedia: School Choice
