News Summary
Penny McCarthy, a 68-year-old Arizona woman, has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the U.S. Marshals Service following her wrongful arrest at gunpoint in March 2023. Misidentified during the execution of a warrant for another individual, the traumatizing experience led McCarthy to relocate due to fear and anxiety. The lawsuit includes allegations such as assault and false imprisonment, highlighting significant flaws in arrest procedures and calling for accountability and broader reforms within law enforcement.
Arizona – A federal civil rights lawsuit has been filed by Penny McCarthy, a 68-year-old woman from Arizona, against the U.S. Marshals Service following her wrongful arrest at gunpoint in March 2023. The arrest, which stemmed from a case of mistaken identity, has resulted in McCarthy experiencing significant trauma, prompting her to relocate out of state due to ongoing fear and anxiety.
In an alarming incident captured on body camera footage, six armed U.S. Marshals surrounded McCarthy’s Phoenix home, instructing her to put her hands up with rifles drawn. They were attempting to execute a warrant for a 70-year-old Canadian woman named Carole Rozak, who has a history of non-violent crimes and an outstanding parole violation from over two decades ago. Despite McCarthy’s attempts to identify herself, asking, “Who am I?” the officers proceeded to handcuff her and take her into custody.
A federal judge subsequently dismissed the legal case against McCarthy, with the U.S. Marshals Service acknowledging its error in arresting her. The 79-page lawsuit, which is being led by attorney Paul Avelar from the Institute for Justice, argues that the marshals failed to conduct basic identity checks prior to the arrest. Additionally, the lawsuit raises concerns that no disciplinary actions have been taken against the involved officers, nor have there been any policy changes within the Marshals Service following the incident.
U.S. lawmakers, including Representative Jim Jordan and Congressman Andy Biggs, have expressed their concerns regarding the treatment of McCarthy and the reliability of arrest procedures, calling for a federal investigation into the matter. In response, the Department of Justice has initiated a probe into McCarthy’s case, which may extend for up to a year.
Despite the government dismissing her case, McCarthy has reported ongoing psychological effects stemming from the wrongful arrest, compelled to sell her home and move from Arizona due to feelings of unsafe and dislocation. The traumatic experiences also include multiple strip searches, exacerbating her anxiety as a survivor of past abuse.
The lawsuit put forth by McCarthy includes allegations of assault, battery, false imprisonment, negligence, malicious prosecution, and violations of her Fourth Amendment rights. McCarthy’s aim is not only to seek justice for her experiences but also to ensure accountability for the mistakes made by federal agents during her arrest. She emphasizes that her ordeal reflects a larger issue concerning mistaken identity arrests and hopes to prevent similar incidents from occurring to others in the future.
While the Marshals Service is aware of the ongoing lawsuit, they have refrained from commenting on the specifics due to the litigation process. The repercussions of this event not only highlight a troubling aspect of law enforcement procedures but also raise questions about the broader implications of such government actions on innocent citizens.
This case symbolizes more than an individual’s battle for justice; it appears to pinpoint systemic flaws that could affect many others if left unaddressed.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
- ABC15
- Wikipedia: Rights of the Accused
- Sacramento Bee
- Google Search: Wrongful Arrest Cases
- AZ Family
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Civil Rights
- The Hill
- Google News: US Marshals Lawsuit
Author: STAFF HERE PHOENIX WRITER
The PHOENIX STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREPhoenix.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Phoenix, Maricopa County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as the Waste Management Phoenix Open, Cactus League Spring Training, and Arizona State Fair. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Greater Phoenix Chamber of Commerce and Visit Phoenix, plus leading businesses in technology and healthcare that power the local economy such as Intel and Banner Health. As part of the broader HERE network, including HERETucson.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Arizona's dynamic landscape.
